Should You Get a Loved One Officially Tested for Dementia?

Should You Get a Loved One Officially Tested for Dementia?

Join the Memory Club & get the free decision guide!

When memory changes become noticeable, families often face a difficult question:

“We can already see the signs… so is there any point in getting a formal diagnosis?”

It’s a fair question—especially when cognitive testing can take several hours, feel emotionally heavy, and doesn’t always “change the outcome” in obvious ways.

But the decision is more nuanced than it first appears.

What a Dementia Evaluation Actually Involves


A full dementia workup is not just one test. It often includes:

  • Detailed cognitive testing (memory, attention, language, reasoning)

  • Medical evaluation (to rule out reversible causes)

  • Brain imaging (like MRI or CT scans)

  • Functional assessments (daily living skills)

Yes—parts of it can take hours. But each piece answers a different question.

The Case For Getting a Diagnosis

1. You Might Be Wrong (And That Matters)

Not all memory loss is dementia.

Conditions like:

  • Depression
  • Sleep disorder
  • Medication side effects
  • Thyroid issues
  • Vitamin deficiencies

…can mimic dementia and are sometimes reversible.

Without testing, you could miss something treatable.

2. It Clarifies Which Type of Dementia

Different types—like Alzheimer’s disease, vascular dementia, or Lewy body dementia—progress differently.

Why that matters:

  • Different medications

  • Different behavioral expectations

  • Different care strategies

Without a diagnosis, families are often guessing.

3. It Helps With Planning (While They Still Can)

A formal diagnosis allows for:

  • Legal decisions (power of attorney, wills)

  • Financial planning

  • Living arrangements

  • Care preferences

Timing is critical—these decisions are best made early.

4. Access to Support and Resources

Many services require documentation:

  • Insurance coverage

  • Memory care programs

  • Clinical trials

  • Support groups

  • Without a diagnosis, access can be limited.


5. It Reduces Family Conflict

Ambiguity creates tension:

  • “They’re fine.”
  • “No, they’re not.”

A clinical evaluation provides a shared reality, which can reduce disagreement and guilt.

The Case Against Getting a Diagnosis

1. Emotional Impact

A diagnosis can feel like:

  • A loss of identity

  • Fear of decline

  • Depression or anxiety

For some individuals, knowing doesn’t help—it harms.

2. It May Not Change Treatment Much

Especially in later stages, treatments for conditions like Alzheimer’s disease are often:

  • Symptom-managing, not curative

  • Modest in effectiveness

Families sometimes feel:

“We went through all that… and nothing really changed.”

3. The Testing Process Can Be Exhausting

Multi-hour testing can lead to:

  • Fatigue

  • Frustration

  • Anxiety

  • Poor performance (which can skew results)

4. Resistance From the Loved One

Some individuals:

  • Refuse testing

  • Feel accused or embarrassed

  • Experience increased distrust

Forcing the issue can damage relationships.

5. Labeling and Stigma

A diagnosis can change how others treat them:

  • Less independence granted

  • Decisions made for them prematurely

  • Social withdrawal

 

The Real Question: How Will This Information Help Your Family Move Forward?


This is the most important lens.

Before scheduling testing, families should ask:

  • Will this change how we care for them?

  • Do we need documentation for legal or medical reasons?

  • Are we trying to confirm something—or hoping to rule something out?

If the answer is “it will guide action,” testing is often worthwhile.

If not, observation and supportive care may be enough—for now.

A Balanced Approach Many Families Take

Instead of jumping straight to full neuropsychological testing, many start with:

  1. A primary care visit

  2. Basic cognitive screening

  3. Blood work to rule out reversible causes

Then escalate if needed.

A Thoughtful Conclusion

Getting a dementia diagnosis is not just a medical decision—it’s a personal, emotional, and practical one.

Sometimes clarity brings relief and direction.
Sometimes it brings weight without benefit.

The goal isn’t just to “know.”

It’s to decide whether knowing will help you love, support, and plan better.

Want more help?

If you’re navigating this decision, you don’t have to figure it out alone. These three organizations offer some of the most trusted guidance for families facing memory concerns.



Back to blog

Leave a comment